by Jenn |
The top 3 performed 2 songs, one chosen by them and one that the judges picked.
Contestants’ Picks:
Casey James – OK, It’s Alright With Me by Eric Hutchinson
- Randy - “That song was just kind of alright with me, too. I wanted to hear more from you, something that was different, unique, interesting.”
- Ellen - “I wish you would have brought it.” “It was alright.”
- Kara - “It’s hard to pick a song that not everyone knows.” “That didn’t work in your favor.”
- Simon - “I would compare that first song to if you were having dinner, that’s the salad.” “That song will leave no lasting affect on the audience what-so-ever.” “I think that was a dud song choice.”
Crystal Bowersox -Come to My Window by Melissa Etheridge
- Randy - “I did not love the arrangement.” “I loved your vocal one it.” “It all worked in the end.”
- Ellen - “That’s your comfort zone.”
- Kara - “You did get a little lost in the arrangement.” “Still a good vocal.”
- Simon - “I don’t think this is the most stunning version we will ever hear.” “You haven’t compromised yourself as an artist.” “It’s a very honest performance.”
Lee DeWyze - Simple Man by Lynyrd Skynyrd
- Randy - “Great song choice.” “You sounded amazing.” “Throwing down!”
- Ellen - “You took this thing seriously.”
- Kara - “You showed us everything you’ve got.” “Round one goes to Lee.”
- Simon - “That song…was absolutely on the money.” “I think you just crushed the other two.”
The Judges’ Picks:
Casey James – Daughters by John Mayor
- Randy - “This fit you like a glove.”
- Ellen - “That was beautiful for you.”
- Kara - “This showed the more artist side of you.”
- Simon - “It was a bit of a lazy arrangement.” “You sounded very, very good on it.”
Crystal Bowersox - Maybe I’m Amazed by Paul McCartney
- Randy - “Great song. Great vocals.”
- Ellen - “That’s what I was hoping you’d do and you did it.”
- Kara - “You really showed parts of your voice that I don’t think we’ve heard until tonight.” “You really pushed.”
- Simon - “You’ve got soul.” “You worked outside of your comfort zone.” “That was terrific.”
Lee DeWyze - Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen
- Randy - “This was your biggest moment at the biggest time on this show.” “Unbelievable!”
- Ellen - “That was stunning.”
- Kara - “You are what this show is all about.” “You are the heart of this show this season.” “You owned the entire night.”
- Simon - “You proved that you are a fantastic singer, a great person.”
We will find out tomorrow night who make it to the finale next week!